Law News, Briefings, Reports, & Legal Intelligence Resources

Cisco, Finjan IP Trial Delayed Until October Due To Pandemic

A California federal judge on Tuesday, 26th May, delayed a trial in Finjan's patent infringement suit against Cisco from June to October because of the COVID-19 pandemic. The judge said she had "high hopes" it would be the first civil jury trial in the district, but the federal court's "enormous backlog" of criminal cases takes priority.
By Simpluris Research
  • Share

Law360 reported that United States District Judge Beth Freeman through a video conference set an October 19 date to start the trial of Israeli software maker Finjan against California technology giant Cisco Systems Inc for cybersecurity patent infringement. Originally set for June 15, the trial was pushed back due to the coronavirus pandemic. 

Judge Freeman told counsel, "I am really disappointed that we can not move this along because I know you are ready. But we have an enormous backlog of criminal cases and they take priority no matter what." 

I am really disappointed that we can not move this along, because I know you are ready. But we have an enormous backlog of criminal cases and they take priority no matter what.
- Judge Freeman

Finjan originally sued Cisco with a lawsuit in January 2017 alleging its products breached five Finjan patents that cover actions to protect computer systems and software from malicious viruses when they connect to the internet. Finjan alleges that Cisco's infringement started when it took technology from a company called Sourcefire Inc. and after that refused to get in a licensing agreement with Finjan. Cisco Inc. declines the claims and has sought to disqualify at least some of the patents asserted in the litigation.




The effects of the pandemic have reached into the judicial system slowing an already backlogged judicial system. The delay is especially long for cases warranting a jury because of the preventative measures needed for social distancing. In April, Judge Freeman warned counsel to prepare for the June 15 trial. At the time, said was "fairly confident" Finjan's patent infringement suit could go before a jury in June and July, even with social distancing at the place. 

However, the Northern District of California's higher judge announced an order for postponing all new civil jury trials through September 30  attributing the judicial system interruption to COVID-19. Judge Freeman explained that the district courts cannot hold more than one jury trial in a courthouse at the same time, and so only two trial dates in October and January would available to both the parties. She added, "I do not have a crystal ball," and proposed that both the parties agree to an October trial date because a January trial could be further delayed with the usual winter flu season and a likely second wave of the coronavirus.

Judge Freeman also cautioned plaintiff and defense attorneys that because of COVID-19 jurors' reactions to being called in would widely vary. The waters of this coronavirus pandemic are vastly uncharted. She said, "there's virtually no experience across the country now."

Get Unlimited Access To Simpluris Insights—FREE
We won't ever sell your information. We'll only send a brief summary of legal industry news once in a while.
Schedule a free, expert consultation with a Simpluris Case Manager
So that we may best serve you, please let us know the following:
Ascertainability Numerosity
Federal-Rule-of-Civil-Procedure-23 Class-action-certification
We're excited to learn about your business.
First, a bit about you.
Something went wrong. Please try again
Class members may visit our case lookup screen to locate information related to your case.
Hi , do any of the following times work for you?
Hi , Please call us at 714-640-5606
All times are . Please allow for 30 minutes.
All available appointment slots are booked for the next few days.
  • Today

  • Tomorrow

  • Day After Tomorrow

  • Day 4

  • Day 5

  • Day 6

Please select at least one time slot.
Something went wrong. Please try again
Thanks , we look forward to meeting you !
Check your email for more info and a calendar invitation.